Rescripted

Women's Health, Your Way

Ask & Search With Clara

Welcome to a new standard for women's health answers.

GIRLHOOD / The Cosmo-Era Advice We Never Thought To Question

The Cosmo-Era Advice We Never Thought To Question

The Cosmo-Era Advice We Never Thought To Question

Raise your hand if you still think about "day to night" when it comes to picking outfits.

I mean, has that Cosmo-era advice ever even come in handy?

I recently came across this video of a woman who's been parting her hair "the opposite way" for over a decade because Seventeen magazine told her to, in an issue she probably read on her bedroom floor as a teenager. It got me thinking about every random tip 2000s-era magazines planted in our brains that we never once thought to question.

One commenter said she's been shaving her legs with conditioner for over twenty years because of something she read in Teen Vogue back in the day. Twenty years, from one stranger's tip in a magazine that no longer even exists.

I grew up on the same content — clips from Cosmo, Seventeen, and Glamour spread across my bedroom floor in Queens — and the nostalgia of it is genuinely funny to me. What isn't funny is remembering those same magazines telling us to count calories and fear carbs, right on the very next page. I think I speak for most millennial women when I say we didn't separate the two; we just believed all of it.

I've spent years unlearning the food part, but I'm not sure I ever unlearned the reflex underneath it: believing whatever's printed with enough confidence, no questions asked. Which feels a little terrifying now that "printed" has become "posted," and instead of three magazines a month, it's thousands of messages a day, from people whose only credential is that they seem confident on camera.

Twenty years is a long time to keep a hair part because one magazine said so, once, decades ago. It makes me wonder what we're believing right now, from someone with a ring light and zero medical degree, that we'll look back on in twenty years and say, "what the hell were we thinking?"

More from GIRLHOOD

I’m in NYC at a conference today, and when I told the woman sitting next to me at lunch about Rescripted, she immediately launched into her own health story. I... Read more
When I was around ten weeks pregnant with my twins, I sat in my OB's waiting room with absolutely no idea what I was supposed to ask. I had a... Read more
I was driving to get coffee with my husband the other day when he turned to me, completely out of nowhere, and said, “Why am I always tired?”I almost laughed,... Read more
I have this problem in motherhood, and it's called grieving-the-moment-while-it's-still-happening.I'm not sure if other moms can relate, but last weekend I took my daughter to see Wicked on Broadway, and... Read more
I haven't read The Love Hypothesis yet (I know, I know), but now that the movie with Lili Reinhart is streaming on Prime Video, it's at the very top of... Read more
There's a big part of the fertility journey that doesn't get enough credit, and spoiler alert: it's everything that happens before IVF.When I first got diagnosed with PCOS (now PMOS,... Read more
I was an athlete my whole life — softball, basketball, cheerleading, more softball, with a theater-kid detour in between. Most of my best friends came out of team sports, the... Read more
If you've ever felt the very specific discomfort of having to pee thirty seconds after you just went, welcome to Girlhood. The burning, the urgency, the sense that something is... Read more
I recently had the pleasure of sitting down with Gabrielle Union-Wade, which, as someone who was a high school cheerleader in the early 2000s, was a major fangirl moment for... Read more
My co-founder Abby sent me a clip of Sara Bareilles talking about her new song, and it instantly brought tears to my eyes.I've always said that sitting in the waiting... Read more